Review: Pizzicato
“One can only praise this recording. Conductor David Bernard convinces with his coherent and idiomatic Mahler conducting and is superbly supported by an excellent and committed orchestra. An often moving warmth characterizes Beethoven’s Third Symphony, which David Bernard conducts in a very inspired manner. He demonstrates not only a keen sense of color, but also of detail, which makes for an interesting rhetoric. Bernard does not miss a single opportunity the composer gives him. The excellent Park Avenue Chamber Symphony also serves as a very inspired instrument.”
Review: Crescendo
"Quite impressive by our European standards. One can only marvel at this release. Beethoven’s Symphony No. 3 immediately captivates with its directness and the musicians' commitment. The tempos are brisk but never rushed, and the conducting highlights the modernity of Beethoven’s writing. The listener appreciates the ensemble’s uniformity, its rich overall sound, and the quality of the sections' contributions. This interpretation is flawless both musically and artistically.
In Mahler’s Symphony No. 5 The conductor perfectly captures the character of the movements, managing an airy and coherent instrumental texture. This is an heroic Mahler but one that avoids heaviness or excessive intention. The musicians of the Park Avenue Chamber Symphony, in an expanded formation, perform as a unified body, with all sections showing remarkable engagement, particularly the glorious brass."
Review: Stereophile
“The opening trumpet fanfare comes up with impressive, round depth, as does the Scherzo's obbligato horn. Woodwind and horn soli are precisely placed on the stage. Focused bass lines ground it firmly...David Bernard brings out plenty of the score's character. The opening dotted rhythms are oppressive in their weighty deliberation; the strings' somber march, while more transparent, remains weighted, and the second theme all but grieves. The Scherzo's second group, slightly selfconscious, is affectionately laid-back. The Adagietto, once it settles, flows in a single purposeful arc; even the big downward swoop is kept within bounds. The Finale is best, vigorous and gracious by turns, the strings bold and confident in the "scraping" fugues...This performance would have brought me to my feet in the hall [and] it's worth considering for audiophiles because of the superior sound.”
Review: ClassicsToday.com
”David Bernard and the Park Avenue Chamber Symphony have tackled big orchestral warhorses for years, and their Galahad-like persistence in face of formidable catalog competition deserves commendation…they brave the Mahler Fifth symphony’s formidable challenges admirably. The cellos and basses display impressive focus and cohesion in the second movement’s soft moments…the strings gain expressive poignancy in the Adagietto, abetted by Bernard’s fluid and animated basic tempo…The tricky first-desk wind and brass solos sport impressive character and agility throughout the performance. One must credit Bernard’s intelligent balancing of contrapuntal strands. What’s more, these musicians never “phone it in”, so to speak, they clearly relish how Mahler gives each orchestral section equal opportunity to shine. I also should mention the superb booklet essays by scholar Vera Micznik and Bernard himself, as well as the vividly detailed engineering.”
Review: The Arts Desk
”Two very different recordings of Mahler’s 5th have recently landed on the doormat, both worth hearing. Bychkov’s 5th symphony is well-prepared, but this work needs to begin sounding craggier and darker. With Bychkov, the funeral march feels too polished, as if it’s playing out in warm sunlight. David Bernard's Park Avenue Chamber Symphony, though polished, has plenty of edge and punch, the sonorities raw and rough when necessary. Bernard milks Mahler’s rhetorical corners for all they’re worth, moments like the massed horns’ whoop up to a high F in the first movement really telling…Lower brass are superb throughout, the second movement’s triumph well-earned. Bernard’s timings for the remaining movements are close to Bychkov’s, a resonant acoustic giving his hard-working strings extra body in the “Adagietto”. This “Rondo-Finale” is earthy, positive and humane. Both discs are worth investigating, Bernard’s coming with an interesting sleeve note linking the symphony to Mahler’s interest in early 20th century science.”
Review: MusicWeb International
“The playing has skill, character and commitment,. Conductor David Bernard knows his way round the symphony. and offers very considered and idiomatic Maher conducting throughout. Here we have energy in the bustling counterpoint, warmth in the lyrical passages – which are often truly con amore – and that compelling narrative arc through each movement which holds our attention in a big symphony. The first movement has the requisite lachrymose power at the outset. Although there is plenty of fire at the “Suddenly faster…Wild” marking, the speed is not too frenetic. The second movement flows well towards the coda’s chorale, and the trumpets sound a fine apotheosis. The “corno obbligato” part of the third movement scherzo is certainly well played, and the agreeable geniality of the Ländler and waltz sections are nicely characterised. The manner is very Viennese, helped by the conductor’s instinctive and persuasive rubato. The strings are excellent in the Adagietto, with good tone and real feeling for this love song. David Bernard sets a middling tempo, taking just about ten minutes, effectively mediating between the seven minutes of Walter and Mengelberg (who both knew the composer), and the twelve or thirteen minutes of a few overindulgent conductors.”
Review: Infodad/Trans Century Communications
“Its aural clarity is impressive…There is a thoughtfulness here to the slower sections, making them more ruminative and questioning than usual; In the third movement, Bernard shows how Mahler stretches dance forms even while inhabiting them…There is an almost oceanic feel to this movement, a sense of constant ebb and flow brought out to fine effect. …Bernard’s reading of the finale is more cohesive than Bychkov’s, with a greater sense of building to a suitable conclusion…Both orchestras perform admirably, both conductors clearly understand this music and have given considerable thought to the best way to present it, and both here show themselves to be quite worthy of Mahler – and prove that his Symphony No. 5 is quite worthy of their time, attention, and very considerable skill.”
Review: Classical Candor
"Bernard maintains a solid, forward-moving rhythm...It’s a steadfast, firmly grounded interpretation that eschews histrionics in favor of an unwavering fidelity to Mahler’s intentions….The celebrated Adagietto emerges perfectly, conveying Mahler’s obvious affection yet not dipping into sentimentality…In the Finale, Maestro Bernard lets the work’s effulgent joy shine radiantly through, concluding a thoroughly enjoyable reading."
Review: Classical Music Sentinel
“It's precisely these immense conflicts and emotive outbursts that conductor David Bernard captures and projects so well. From the opening movement's forceful oppression, through frays and skirmishes, love, all leading to the final movement's frenzied expression of ecstatic overwhelming joy, he always knows exactly which section(s) of the orchestra on which to focus his attention, in order to underline these conflicts…they play with impressive impact and convincing gusto, and also lend the beautiful Adagietto all the expressive care it calls for. You can even feel the elation within the final pages of the last movement emanate from each and every instrumentalist.”
Review: Broadway World Classical Music
"Maestro Bernard leads the orchestra on a take-no-prisoners journey that stirs the emotions and our very souls. The musicians are with him every step of the way...it is utterly thrilling, riveting, and breathtaking...this is a CD that should find a place in all music libraries, an honored place among the many recordings of the Fifth Symphony. It is truly a first among equals."
Link to Listen
https://bit.ly/HeroicBeethoven3Mahler5
Release Info/Program
Recursive Classics RC5956731
Park Avenue Chamber Symphony
David Bernard, Conductor
Mahler Symphony No. 5
I. Trauermarsch. In gemessenen Schritt. Streng. Wie ein Kondukt (With measured tread. Strict. Like a procession)
II. Stürmisch bewegt, mit größter Vehemenz
(Stormy. With utmost vehemence)
III. Scherzo. Kräftig, nicht zu schnell
(Vigorous, not too fast)
IV. Adagietto. Sehr langsam
(Very slow)
V. Rondo-Finale. Allegro